Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 vs Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD: Price, Specifications and Detailed Comparison

Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 vs Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD

Farmers' selection of a tractor is a crucial decision, as the tractor's size, condition of the soil, implements, and type of agricultural work determine the tractor's suitability. There are several models of Mahindra Tractors and Swaraj Tractors in the 45-50 HP range, and farmers tend to compare the models on the basis of the following factors: Engine performance, Horsepower, Transmission, Lifting capacity, Drivetrain, PTO and overall versatility.

Farmers considering purchasing a tractor with good performance for farm use may want to consider either of the two tractors, Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 and Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD. The Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 makes 49 HP vs 46 HP in the Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD. Both of the tractors have 3-cylinder engines and have nearly equal engine capacity.

If you're familiar with the two, however, there are some differences that you should note. The Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 is available in 2WD, and the Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD in 4WD. The listed lifting capacity of the Swaraj is 2500 kg, and it has a fuel tank of 70 litres and oil-immersed brakes.

Let's have a detailed comparison of the Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 tractor and the Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD tractor to understand which tractor is better suited for the farmers' needs.

Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 vs Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD: Key Highlights

The key specifications of both tractors show that they belong to a similar power segment but are designed with different priorities.

• Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1: 49 HP
• Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD: 46 HP
• Mahindra engine capacity: 3470 CC
• Swaraj engine capacity: 3478 CC
• Mahindra engine cylinders: Not available in the provided data
• Swaraj engine cylinders: 3
• Mahindra drivetrain: 2WD
• Swaraj drivetrain: 4WD
• Mahindra gearbox: 12 Forward + 3 Reverse
• Swaraj gearbox: 12 Forward + 3 Reverse / 12 Forward + 12 Reverse Side Shift
• Swaraj engine rated RPM: 2000 RPM
• Mahindra PTO: Multi-speed PTO and SLIPTO
• Swaraj PTO: VERSA PTO/MRPTO
• Swaraj lifting capacity: 2500 kg
• Swaraj fuel tank: 70 litres
• Mahindra steering: Power Steering
• Swaraj steering: Balanced Power Steering / Differential Power Steering
• Mahindra brakes: Not available in the provided data
• Swaraj brakes: Oil-immersed brakes

Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 vs Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD Engine Comparison

Performance is among the factors that are paramount when buying a tractor. The engine is an important component of the tractor that is responsible for various functions depending on the type of activity the tractor is used for, including ploughing, cultivating, Rotavating, sowing and pulling agricultural equipment.

The Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 comes with a 3470 CC engine and produces 49 HP. It has a power rating of 49 hp which is slightly more than the horsepower of Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD.

The Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD is powered by a 3478 CC engine which generates a horsepower of 46 HP. The engine has a speed rating of 2000 RPM. While the Swaraj has a bit more engine capacity, the Mahindra's engine boasts a high horsepower rating.

The difference in engine size is quite minimal, with just 8 CC apart between both the tractors. Thus, farmers should not only look at the engine size when purchasing a tractor. Requirements for drives, gearboxes, hydraulics and implements are also not to be overlooked.

Horsepower Comparison

The Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 is rated at 49 HP, which is 3 HP more than the Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD.

A higher horsepower may be beneficial for rigorous tasks and when farmers frequently run implements that require a significant amount of horsepower. The Mahindra in this comparison can, therefore, be marketed to customers who want a more powerful tractor.

Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD outputs 46 HP, making it a strong power machine for several agricultural uses. The 4WD system provides the traction benefits needed, while its lower power is balanced.

In real-world terms, it should depend not only on horsepower, but also on what the horse is doing.

Transmission and Gearbox Comparison

The transmission is a critical part of the tractor as the different kinds of agricultural work demand different working speeds.

The Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 comes with a 12 Forward + 3 Reverse gearbox. It's also equipped with a dual clutch. This transmission system offers several speeds for various field and transportation uses.

The Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD comes with an EZE-SHIFT fully constant mesh transmission with 1/R inline. Depending on configuration, it has either 12 Forward + 3 Reverse or 12 Forward + 12 Reverse side-shift gearboxes.

The side-shift feature may be helpful in situations where many forward/backward movements are needed. Can also offer increased flexibility for some implement uses.

Both tractors do have several gear ratios; however, the Swaraj tractor also has some flexibility with the transmission configurations.

PTO Comparison

When powering tractor implements, the Power Take-Off, or PTO, is a must. Rotavators and other PTO driven machines require power from the tractor's PTO system.

Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 comes with a Multi Speed PTO and SLIPTO. This enables the tractor to be operated with a variety of implements.

The Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD comes with VERSA PTO/MRPTO. Its listed PTO options include 540+540E (O) / 540+R (O).

Both tractors can then be used to power a range of agricultural implements. Farmers should first find out the PTO requirements associated with the farm implements that are currently on their farms and then choose the tractor that will meet these needs.

Hydraulic and Lifting Capacity

Another consideration is the hydraulic performance of tractors, especially if the farmers are the ones who are using heavy implements.

Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD can accommodate a maximum load of 2500 kg. This enables it to accommodate a wide variety of agricultural machines as well as larger machines.

The lifting power of Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 is not included in the comparison data. As such, it is not possible to directly compare the data provided with one another numerically.

Heavy implement farmers should take careful note of hydraulic capacity before buying a tractor. Also, the weight and hydraulic specifications of the implement should be considered.

2WD vs 4WD: A Major Difference

The primary difference between these two models of tractor is their drivetrain.

The Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 is a 2WD tractor, whereas the Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD has a 4WD drivetrain.

A 2WD tractor may be appropriate for farmers who primarily operate on hard and relatively flat farmland. It can be used for most field operations, farm transportation and general farm tasks.

In contrast, a 4WD tractor has four-wheel drive. This can help in poor soil conditions such as loose, muddy, wet or uneven soils. It can be very advantageous when the tractor has to operate in difficult terrain or in tasks where extra traction is needed.

Thus, the Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD may be suitable for farmers with difficult soil conditions, and a 2WD tractor may be sufficient for farmers working on mostly firm and level land.

Brakes and Steering Comparison

The Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD comes with oil-immersed brakes. These brakes can be used for durability and provide consistent braking performance that is ideal for agricultural applications and tractor hauling.

The Swaraj also features Balanced Power Steering / Differential Power Steering, which gives steering assistance while operating in the field.

Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 is fitted with Power steering. There is no information included in the provided data about the brake specification.

Power steering may help to ease the strain on the operator's hands when operating the tractor for extended periods of time, especially when making numerous turns in the field.

Fuel Tank Capacity

The amount of fuel in the tank determines the duration of the tractor's operation.

Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD has a 70-litre fuel tank. For farmers with long working hours outside of the field, its larger tank may be advantageous in decreasing the need to refuel.

There is no information about the fuel tank capacity of Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ V1 DI in the specifications provided, so a direct comparison cannot be made.

Dimensions of Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD

The wheelbase of Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD is 2160/2240 mm. It has an overall length of 3730 mm and an overall width of 1920 mm.

The size of these dimensions reflects the tractor's 4WD operation and the configuration used for heavy-duty agricultural applications.

There is no information on the dimensions of the Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 in the data supplied.

Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 vs Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD Price

The supplied comparison data lists the ex-showroom price of both tractors as Not Available.

The price of a tractor may be different depending on the dealership, location, tractor variant, accessories and offers. So, it's advisable to get the ex-showroom and on-road price from an authorised dealer beforehand before buying the tractor.

The final cost can also include registration, insurance, implements and other applicable expenses, depending on the purchase requirements.

Which Tractor Is Better for Agricultural Operations?

Both tractors may be appropriate for various kinds of farming needs.

The Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 has a horsepower advantage, with its 49 HP rating. Farmers may consider this tractor if they desire a higher-powered 2WD tractor for general farm use, transport and applicable implement use.

Swaraj has been much more keen on the traction and implement handling aspect in the Swaraj 855 FE 4WD, however. Heavy-duty farmers preferring to operate larger implements will find 2500 kg lifting capacity appealing, and its 4WD system will help them in difficult field conditions.

For dry, firm and relatively flat terrain, Mahindra's 2WD model might be enough. Swaraj's 4WD system can be beneficial in wet, muddy, uneven or loose soil.

Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 vs Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD: Which One Should You Buy?

The answer depends on the farmer's priorities.

Choose Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 if:

• You want a higher 49 HP tractor.
• You primarily work on firm and relatively level land.
• You are looking for a 2WD tractor.
• You need a tractor with a 12 Forward + 3 Reverse gearbox.
• You want a multi-speed PTO and SLIPTO setup.
• Your farming requirements do not necessarily require 4WD traction.

Choose Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD if:

• You require a 4WD tractor.
• You frequently work in wet, loose or challenging soil.
• You need greater traction during field operations.
• You want a listed 2500 kg lifting capacity.
• You prefer oil-immersed brakes.
• You want the flexibility of 12 Forward + 3 Reverse or 12 Forward + 12 Reverse Side Shift configurations.
• A larger 70-litre fuel tank is important for your operations.

Final Verdict

In the comparison of the Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 tractor with the Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD, both tractors have their own merits.

Compared to the Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD, the Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 generates 49 HP, which is 3 HP more. Equipped with a 3470 cc engine, dual clutch, power steering and a Multi Speed PTO with SLIPTO and a 12 Forward + 3 Reverse gearbox. It is 2WD, suitable for farmers who mostly farm on solid and generally flat terrain.

The Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD has an engine capacity of 3478 CC and generates a power of 46 HP. It does have a 4WD system, 2,500 kgs of lifting capacity, oil-immersed braking and 70 litre fuel tank and transmission options. For farmers looking for better traction and heavy implement-handling, these traits are attractive options.

To sum up, the Mahindra Yuvo Tech+ 585 DI V1 may be the more suitable choice for those seeking increased power and overall 2WD capabilities in farming operations, whereas the Swaraj 855 FE Protek 4WD might be the preferred choice for farmers who value the power of 4WD drive, lifting capacity, and performance in tough tractive situations.

Farmers need to research the current dealer price before buying, as well as the financing terms, the warranty, the service available, fuel economy and whether it's compatible with their existing machinery. Ultimately, it all depends on the soil, acreage, crops, implements and daily workload of a farm to decide on which tractor to use.